I think that a rulebased optimizer has the unvaluable positive side of being always predictable. The oracle database 11 g reference makes no mention of the venerable rule and choose options and the demise of the rule based optimizer was therefore treated as fact. The rule hint ignores the table and index statistics and uses basic heuristics to generate an execution plan. As time passed from oracle 9i to 10g, we harnessed hints less, trusting the cbo and by oracle 11g, it started to be frowned upon unless you had a very strong use case for hinting. Now that oracle database 11g release 2 is out, more and more folks are considering upgrading to 11g. If an index scan is available, the optimizer may choose it over a full table scan. The oracle database 11g reference makes no mention of the venerable rule and choose options and the demise of the rule based optimizer was therefore treated as fact. Oracle toad expert blog for developers, admins and data analysts. A value of 10 means that the cost of an index access path is onetenth the normal cost of. The rule mode is ignored if the statement contains hints other than the rule hint itself, hence their cost based plan. Rule the rule hint should be considered deprecated as it is dropped from oracle9i2. With a large number of oracle shops using the rule based optimizer rbo, migration to cost based optimization cbo will become a important task when migrating to oracle10i, where the rbo will disappear.
Free oracle magazine subscriptions and oracle white papers. For oracle applications, it was ironic that oracle apps used the rbo, and oracle made a big deal out of announcing that oracle applications 11i ebusiness suite was moving to the costbased sql. New oracle10g sql optimizer hints by donald burleson in data management on april 26, 2004, 12. Yes, the rulebased optimizer still lives in oracle. The cheapest plan is the one that will use the least amount of resources cpu, memory, io, etc. The following considerations apply to both the cost based and rule based approaches. I was in the latter scenario, as my first oracle 11g database environment required not just new data, but a new database weekly and a requirement for me to guarantee.
This section describes new performance features of oracle database 10g release 1. Ive seen instead oracle 10g changing execution plans from night to day, leading to turtlelike performances. Rule hint still popular in oracle 10g for many years since the release of oracle8, oracle has threatened to phaseout the rulebased optimizer rbo. The functionality is still present but no new functionality has been included in it and it is no longer supported by oracle. So oracles implementation of it is two features, adaptive cursor sharing and cardinality feedback, and of course its different in many ways from the other products on the market, but the concept that the database vendors are getting into is, well, lets take some of the runtime data and send it back to the optimizer. Motivation behind cbo is to come up with the cheapest execution plan available for each sql statement. Oracle 12c elevates the behavior of optimizer at the instrumental level by. The rule based optimizer has not been updated in nearly a decade and is not recommended for production use because the rbo does not support any new features of oracle since 1994 such as bitmap indexes, table. Without the hint, the optimizer could make a query optimization decision to use the best plan generated without the transformation, instead of the best plan for the transformed query.
Can anyone tell me if there is still a rule based optimiser in 10g, i have heard that it has been removed. The parameter accepts one of a list of valid string values corresponding to the release numbers, such as 11. The rbo was in use for many years, and lots of applications were developed using the rulebased optimizer. True or false optimizer mode and tuning goals charles. This is the cost based approach designed to provide the best response time. This hint causes the optimizer to make these choices. Yes, the rulebased optimizer still lives in oracle database. Earlier, the only optimizer in the oracle database was the rulebased optimizer rbo. This means the optimizer will no longer operate under rule mode rbo when a table has no statistics. Upgrading from 9i to 11g and the implicit migration from rbo. Therefore, even though you gave the index hint, the optimizer might not. Ask tom cost rule based optimizer behaviour oracle. It should be noted that the optimizer hints only cause oracle to apply the optimizer to the sql, and additional hints can still be added for further tuning. Up until the release of oracle8i, the rule based optimizer often generated a faster execution plan than cost based optimization.
Optimizer mode hints are used to redirect the overall optimizer goal. The end of rule based optimization in oracle 10g by scott stephens in data centers on may 24, 2004, 9. Nov 20, 2001 there is no such thing as a rule based query well, you can use the rule hint but thats really not the same. The optimizer recognizes such situations based on unique and primary key constraints on the tables. There is a method to automate the gathering of stats only for objects that need it. Oracle decided to dismiss the rule based optimizer from version 10g, leaving the cost based one as the only choice. Most often, if the optimizer thinks the cost is high with index, even though you specify it in hints, the optimizer will ignore and continue for full table scan. Oracle10g will only support the costbased optimizer cbo. There is a hint in the cost based optimizer to have this happen as well. The correct selectivity and cost is critical for the oracle optimizer to allow it to make the correct decision in selecting an execution plan when parsing an. The rule based optimizer is a sql query optimizer that uses heuristic rules to derive optimal query execution plans.
However, if you are currently on oracle 9i then you will have to tackle both the upgrade to a new release and the migration from the rulebased optimizer rbo to the costbased optimizer cbo. The rulebased optimizer has not been updated in nearly a decade and is not recommended for production use because the rbo does not support any new features of oracle since 1994 such as bitmap indexes, table. Apr 26, 2004 new oracle10g sql optimizer hints by donald burleson in data management on april 26, 2004, 12. Sep 21, 2011 i was reminded of this story on reading an otn discussion on whether the rule based optimizer is still available in oracle database 11g. The rule based optimizer rbo is now obsolete in oracle 10g.
The following object query properties force the cbo to be used even when the rule. You can use optimizer hints with sql statements to alter execution plans. Basically, the rbo used a set of rules to determine how to execute a query. Optimizer hints are an interesting feature of oracle. However, a simple experiment will prove that the rule based optimizer is alive and well in oracle database 11g. I think that a rule based optimizer has the unvaluable positive side of being always predictable. I know what its declared in oracle 10g rule hint is not supported and rbo is not supported, but rule hint. Hints give us the opportunity, in cases where we have superior knowledge about the database, to influence the optimizer. The most common mode for sql tuning is the rule hint, which is used when you suspect that the cbo is using a suboptimal execution plan. Hints, optimizer directives can be a better name as jonathan lewis advises, can be very dangerous sometimes.
Oracle decided to dismiss the rulebased optimizer from version 10g, leaving the costbased one as the only choice. Oracle, rulebased optimization,rbo costbased optimization,cbo hint. Optimizer is the key driver component in the execution of sql query in oracle database. Although the rbo was depreciated in oracle database 10g, the rule mode and hint are still honored assuming the query can actually use the rbo. They may behave differently release to release, they do not produce. You can use grep and strings to get them directly from the oracle executable. Oracle optimizer hints oracle optimizer hints when using. Hence oracle9i release 2 is the last release to support the rbo.
With solutions for toad for oracle, toad for mysql, toad for sql server, db2, sap and more. When i changed the query to run on rule based optimizer, i go the result in say less than 30 sec. All applications should be converted to use the cost based optimizer as the rule based optimizer is not supported in oracle 10g and above releases. An optimizer hint is a code snippet within an sql statement controlling the decisions of the optimizer. I asked him why and he said that the siebel application defaults to rule based optimization. On one hand, the documentation goes out of its way to tell you to use them sparingly, but on the other hand, you can choose from more than 60 hints in 10g and more than 70 in 11g 64 and 71, to be precise. It is only present to provide backwards compatibility during the migration to the query optimizer cost based optimizer. As with oracle 10g, there is only cbo, there is no imperative need to set this parameter to use the cbo.
This hint can be used with either rule based or cost based optimization. Please give me all the negative impacts of this hint in 10g. A value of 10 means that the cost of an index access path is onetenth the normal cost of an index access path. The rulebased optimizer is no longer supported in oracle database 10g release 1 10. Not that i dont trust him, but i had the impression that cost based was the way to go. If not analyzed, you can set table, index for analyze. My doubt is will this hint create any problem if my db is upgraded to 10g. If an index was available on a table, the rbo rules said to always use the index. Jul 22, 20 the rulebased optimizer is no longer supported in oracle database 10g release 1 10. An effective approach for query tuning involves enabling the rule based optimizer either through a rule hint, or by changing the sessionlevel optimizer goal with the following sql statement. Dec 19, 2011 the rule mode is ignored if the statement contains hints other than the rule hint itself, hence their cost based plan. Remote dba oracle10g optimizer rule costbased optimizer 10g. Avoid using an index that fetches many rows from the driving table when you can use. What drew me to investigate the rule based optimizer.
We do not provide patches or new release for versions or products that are retired, discontinued or cloud based solutions. The rulebased optimization is available for backward compatibility with. Oracle 12c optimizer enhancements eye on databases. The driving table is the table we will join from that is join to other tables. The optimizer generates the execution plan based on the presence of the bind. Ask tom rule based optimizer used consider using cbo. Oracle rule based optimizer rbo prior to version 10. The user wants the first 10 employees of department 20 to be displayed as.
Oracle optimizer hints when using cost based optimization, it is possible to. It will rarely choose to use an index on column referenced using an or statement. Oracle database 11g new features adaptive cursor sharing. Query executes in seconds with the rule hint and several. Performance tuning enhancements in oracle database 10g.
The rbo was in use for many years, and lots of applications were developed using the rule based optimizer. Switching from rulebased optimizer to costbased oracle. The choose and rule optimizer hints are no longer supported. However, if you are currently on oracle 9i then you will have to tackle both the upgrade to a new release and the migration from the rule based optimizer rbo to the cost based optimizer cbo. Dec 21, 2009 now that oracle database 11g release 2 is out, more and more folks are considering upgrading to 11g. Optimizer defaults are adequate for most operations, but not all. The use of or statements confuses older versions of the cost based optimizer cbo. I cannot observe any differences in execution plans with or without the hint and on my system both run with rbo.
However, it will influence the the plan either to have a the first rows as soon as possible. Is it possible to set up a database schema so that it the optimizer always uses rule based rather than cost. With a large number of oracle shops using the rulebased optimizer rbo, migration to costbased optimization cbo will become a important task when migrating to oracle10i, where the. View notes oracle optimizer hints from dbst 651 at university of maryland, university college. The end of rulebased optimization in oracle 10g by scott stephens in data centers on may 24, 2004, 9. Rule hint still popular in oracle 10g for many years since the release of oracle8, oracle has threatened to phaseout the rule based optimizer rbo. There are some cases where the use of an index slowed down a query. The oracle hint list is inside the oracle executable and you can extract the oracle hint list easily with unix commands. Based on this information, you might be able to choose a more efficient execution plan. This hint explicitly chooses the costbased approach to optimize a sql. Index skip scanning in oracle 9i and above allow indexes to be used even when the leading edge is not referenced. The application designer can use hints in sql statements to specify how the statement should be executed. The rulebased optimizer rbo will no longer be supported when oracle9i is desupported.
There is no such thing as a rule based query well, you can use the rule hint but thats really not the same. Anyone using oracle 10g should be sure to use the 10. For oracle applications, it was ironic that oracle apps used the rbo, and oracle made a big deal out of announcing that oracle applications 11i ebusiness suite was moving to the cost based sql. Earlier, the only optimizer in the oracle database was the rule based optimizer rbo.
995 679 229 1288 282 1085 607 232 1073 770 994 612 50 587 976 1210 807 1169 633 946 373 1527 331 482 70 705 904 228 776 1378